Horse racing vs football betting in the UK - where do you get more value?
-
@tom_slots Brilliant data mate! That in-play football ROI is mental though - what's your strategy there? I've always avoided it thinking the margins would be terrible.
-
The problem with these comparisons is that horse racing has such massive variance. You could have 10 losing bets then hit a 25/1 winner that makes your ROI look amazing. Football is more consistent returns but lower ceiling. Depends what kind of punter you are psychologically.
-
@lucy_wins That's actually mathematically quantifiable using the Sharpe ratio. For any betting strategy:
Sharpe Ratio = (Mean Return - Risk-free Rate) / Standard Deviation of Returns
If we assume risk-free rate = 0 for simplicity:
SR = μ / σWhere μ = average return per bet, σ = standard deviation
A higher Sharpe ratio indicates better risk-adjusted returns. In my experience, football typically has Sharpe ratios around 0.15-0.25, while horse racing ranges from 0.05-0.40 depending on your approach. The ceiling is higher for horses but so is the risk of ruin.
-
@ukgambler99 It's mostly value laying in the Championship and League One. Back the underdog pre-match, then lay them off when they inevitably go behind. Lower leagues are so unpredictable but the in-play markets often overreact to early goals. Nothing fancy, just patient value hunting.
-
Fascinating stuff @james_uk - never thought to apply Sharpe ratios to betting but makes perfect sense. @tom_slots your Championship strategy sounds solid, might have to give that a go. Still think the best football betting sites uk are missing a trick not offering better horse racing markets though.
-
All this analysis is great but sometimes you just have to trust your gut. I backed Leicester at 5000/1 to win the Premier League - no amount of mathematical modelling would have suggested that was value, but it was the bet of a lifetime.
-
@sarah_g That wasn't gut though was it? That was a once-in-a-generation anomaly. You can't build a sustainable betting strategy around Leicester 2016. Might as well buy lottery tickets.
-
Getting a bit philosophical here but isn't all gambling ultimately about those rare moments when everything aligns? @sarah_g The maths helps you survive between the big hits, but the big hits are what we're all really chasing.
-
Thread's gone off on a tangent but that's the beauty of it I suppose. Still think horses offer better fundamental value - football markets are just too efficient now with all the smart money and algorithmic betting. Horses still have that human element that creates pricing errors.
-
@ukgambler99 Probably right mate. The efficiency argument is compelling - football is analysed to death these days while horse racing still has that artisan feel to the analysis. Been doing some research into French racing markets as well, seems even less efficient than UK.